Clericalism is real, and really bad stuff. The moral rot at the core of all this has its roots not only the human condition conceived more generally, but also specifically in clericalism. Once priests are treated the way characteristic of clericalism, it is a short next step for them to start thinking the rules that apply to others do not apply to them.
If pervasive, nearly-uncloseted homosexuality in the preisthood were the primary cause of the current crisis, it would not be the true that for hundreds of years there have been institutional cover-ups for clerical sexual abuse. We need to get all sexually active clergy out of ministry, of course, but until we deal with clericalism...the core problem will remain.
@peepingThomist I don't quite follow, could you reword the first sentence?
@peepingThomist Yes, I realised that after I wrote. The sentence I didn't understand was: "If pervasive, nearly-uncloseted homosexuality in the preisthood were the primary cause of the current crisis, it would not be the true that for hundreds of years there have been institutional cover-ups for clerical sexual abuse."
@Matthew that's what I figured, so I tried to respond to that. I'm off to Mass. Have a great day!
@peepingThomist @Matthew I think the knee jerk reaction against the use of the term "clericalism" is that it has been applied by the Pope and his advisors to describe orthodox bishops. So when people hear the Pope decry clericalism, they hear him decrying orthodoxy.
Add to that the fact that the bishops implicated in this mess are not from the group that Pope Francis labels clerical, but rather the ones he supports, and you can understand the resistance to his use of the term.
Clericalism cuts across the "liberal" / "orthodox" divide. The crucial thing is whether a culture encourages all Christians to respond fully to the universal call to holiness, or instead treats some people as called to holiness more than others are. That leads the "elect" to think they are in some ways exempt from laws that apply to the mass of humanity.
RCsocial.net — a friendly social networking space for those with an interest in Catholicism.